评“《自然》评出的2012年五大挑战性科学实验”

Comments on "Frontier experiments: Tough science-Five experiments as hard as finding the Higgs"

逐条分析了《自然》评出的五项前沿实验:(1)寻找外星生命的"蛛丝马迹",(2)看穿手性分子的"镜像",(3)寻找额外的空间维度,(4)捕捉引力波,(5)对千克进行重新定义。得出了前两个实验是近期不可能实现的伟大理想,后三个是将物理学拉向泥潭的谬论。

The five frontier experiments published on Nature are commented item by item： spotting distant signs of life, seeing through the molecular mirror, looking for extra dimensions, catching a gravity wave, redefining the kilogram. It is concluded that the first two experiments are great ideals that are impossible to realize in recent years, the last three are false theories puiling physics into morass.