征服男性的妖妇与走向堕落的反抗——潘金莲与嘉尔曼、华莱丽、娜娜之比较

Comparison of Pan Jinglian with Carman,Valerie and Nana: Enchantresses Subduing Men and Fighting Against Degeneration

对中外名著中几位个性鲜明的女性形象作了比较分析,认为她们在出身、遭遇和对不幸命运的反抗等方面都有某种相似之处,尤其是以妖艳征服男性、以堕落进行反抗,是其共同的特征。但她们又有明显的差异。潘金莲只能成为西门庆的性奴,从根本上说,她也是一个悲剧人物;而华莱丽和娜娜却有自己相对的独立性,她们与各种男人的逢场作戏,都是有价码的交易。

This article has made comparisons and analysis on some female characters with prominent personalities in Chinese and foreign literary works. It finds that there are some kinds of similarities in their family backgrounds, life experiences, fighting against their unfortunate fates and so on, especially in their subduing men with their enchantment and fighting against their own degeneration. On the other hand, a lot of differences can be found between them. Pan Jinglian＇ s is treated only as a sexual slaver- y by her lover, which reveals she is a tragedy at all. But for Valerie and Nana, they independently join in the fun on occasion with various men, which are always money deals.