驳赵幹所在画院为宋画院之说

On the Argument of the Place where Zhao gan was Painting in was not

韩刚《南唐画院有无再考》否认五代存在画院,赵幹为南唐画院画家也随之被否认,赵幹也被定为北宋画院画家。但从《圣朝名画评》和《图画见闻志》两书中《赵幹》条的记述本身去研究,其所述"画院"所指并不是"北宋画院",而确为"南唐画院"。

Doctor HanGang has denied the existence of art gallery in the Five dynasties period in his paper On the Second Research on the Existence of Southern Tang Dynasty Art Gallery,and he also denied that Zhao gan was the painter of Southern Tang dynasty art gallery,and Zhao gan was named as the Northern Song dynasty painter after Doctor Han gang's opinion had been proposed.But when people is about to research on the detail description in Reviews of Song Dynasty Paintings and Deep Though of Paintings,which pointed out that the art gallery was not the northern Song art gallery,but Southern Tang dynasty art gallery.