“醉驾不必一律入罪”之再分析

Reanalysis on "Not All Drunken Driving Need Be Incriminated"

"醉驾不必一律入罪"论引起了司法界较大的争议。文章认为并不是一切醉酒驾车行为都有社会危害性、应受刑法处罚性和刑事违法性,故并非一切"醉驾"行为都应该入罪。应当运用当然解释的方法使刑法和行政法相衔接,避免出现"醉驾"不受任何处罚或者处罚过轻的情形。

The theory that not all drunken driving need be incriminated has caused great disputes in judicial circles.This article states that not all drunken driving has social harmfulness,should be subject to criminal penalty,or has criminal illegality,so not all ＂drunken driving＂ should be convicted.We should connect the criminal law and the administrative law through natural interpretation,and avoid such situations as ＂drunken driving＂ is not punished at all or just punished too lightly.