分析方法与辩证方法的兼容——以段忠桥教授的哲学方法为例的分析

On Compatibility of Analytic and Dialectic Methods——An analysis on case of Prof. Duan Zhongqiao's philosophical methodology

段忠桥教授的学术研究涉及历史唯物主义、国外马克思主义和政治哲学三大领域。透过这些主要的研究成果可见,段忠桥教授一方面运用了逻辑分析、语义分析和语境分析等分析方法;一方面运用了内在关系辩证法。可以说,段忠桥教授的哲学方法正是分析方法与辩证方法兼容的方法,也正是这种哲学方法使其研究成果具有了很强的说服力。这足以证明,分析方法与辩证方法并非如同分析马克思主义和辩证法马克思主义所主张的那样是相互对立的,而是相互兼容的,二者之间是一种内在关系。

Professor Duan Zhongqiao＇s academic explorations cover historical materialism, Western Marxism and political philosophy. Through survey of his major achievements in those fields it can be found that he employs on the one side such methods as logical analysis, semantic analysis and context analysis, and on the other hand dialectics of internal relations. It can be concluded that Prof. Duan＇s philosophical methodology is integration of analytic and dialectic methods and that it is this methodology that grants his academic findings particular persuasiveness. This is a proof that analytic and dialectic methods are not mutually contradictory as suggested by scholars of analytic Marxism and dialectic Marxism; instead, they are mutual compatible. Between them is internal relation.