行政法类司法解释能否成为行政法的渊源——对我国香港地区及国外法院司法解释制度的考察与借鉴

Can Administrative Judicial Interpretations be Origin of Administrative Law

司法解释作为一种重要的法律解释,一直为理论界和实务界所重视,其研究也日臻成熟和系统,但是,这并不意味着人们对于司法解释地位已经达成普遍的共识。相反,关于司法解释地位和作用的说法,关于司法解释能否成为行政法的渊源问题,仍然是"仁者见仁、智者见智"。以法院的司法解释为出发点加以剖析,并引入国外法院行政法类司法解释制度中有益部分为我所用,对我国行政法类司法解释制度的设计和完善有所裨益。

Judicial interpretation is one of the most important interpretations. It has been paid more and more attention to by the theoretical circle and the practical field. The research on it is becoming more and more mature and consummate. But this does not mean that people have reached a general consensus for the status of judicial in- terpretation. On the contrary, the debate of the status and role of the judicial interpretation, and how it can origi- nate the administrative law, is still not concluded. This article starts from the Court＇ s judicial interpretation, and introduces the parts of the foreign countries that might be beneficial to the design and improvement of the judicial interpretation on administrative law.