生物领域中断言性结论导致的说明书公开不充分问题浅析
摘要
生物领域专利申请说明书中仅给出断言性结论常常导致说明书公开不充分。申请人和审查员之间的争论焦点往往在于对断言性结论和定性实验数据的把握。本文以说明书充分公开的立法宗旨为出发点,结合几个生物领域中的典型案例以及世界各专利局对上述问题的处理思路,简单探讨断言性结论导致的说明书公开不充分问题。
出处
《中国发明与专利》
2013年第3期96-100,共5页
China Invention & Patent
二级参考文献15
-
1(佚名).世界制药巨头礼来与美Ariad专利之争进入第二回合[EB/OL].http://www.148corn.eom/html/526/22294.html,Nov20,2010.
-
2Shaw BZ. En Banc Court confirms existence of WrittenDescription Requirement Separate from Enablement [ J ]. Mondaq Business Briefing, 2010, (5) : 1-4.
-
3The Bureau of Nat' 1 Affairs, Inc. Interview with Laurence Tribe on Supreme Court Review of Amgen, Inc v Chugai Pharmaceutical Co [ J ]. Pat Trademark Copyright, 1991, 42(2) : 466-468.
-
4Anvaripour A, Elson VM. United States : En Banc Federal Circuit confirms Section 112, Paragraph 1 includes a Separate Written Description Requirement [ J ]. Mondaq Business Briefing, 2010, (4):1-4.
-
5Mescher RM. Patent Law : Best mode disclosure-genetic engineers get their trade secret and their patent too? [ J ]. Intellectual Property Law Rev, 1994, 18(1) : 183.
-
6Hampar B. Patenting of recombinant DNA technology : The Deposit Requirement [ J ~. Pat Trademark, 1985, 67(7) : 569.
-
7(Anonymous). Ariad, MIT patent on transcription factor fails written description test-Some material errors, but no inequitable condllct [ J ]. Uiotcchnology Law Rep, 2009, 28(3) : 363-365.
-
8Murdoch CE, Simon BM, et al. Pluripotent patents make prime time : An analysis of the emerging landscape [ J ]. Nat Biotech, 2010, 28(6) : 557-559.
-
9Karczewski LA. Biotechnological gene patent applications : The implications of the USPTO Written Description Requirement Guidelines on the biotechnology industry [ J ]. McGeorge Law Rev, 2000, 31(4):1043-1086.
-
10Holman CM. Is Lilly written description a paper tiger : A comprehensive assessment of the impact of Eli Lilly and its progeny in the Courts and PTO [ J ]. Albany Law J Sci Tech, 2007, 17(1) : 69-80.
-
1吲哚满酮衍生物的制备方法[J].化工中间体导刊,2005(18):27-27.
-
2王玉桂.浅谈化学领域权利要求得不到说明书支持的答复[J].中国发明与专利,2016,0(3):49-53. 被引量：1
-
3吕艳玲.化学领域专利申请文件撰写之实验数据[J].广州化工,2016,44(16):28-29. 被引量：3
-
4闵艳林,龙斌.化学实验教学中的环保教育问题浅析[J].黄冈师范学院学报,2007,27(6):75-77. 被引量：3
-
5茆建军.氢氧化铜与氨水反应的实验探究[J].化学教育,2006,27(6):55-55. 被引量：3
-
62-取代的2-苯基-1，3-二酮化合物[J].化工中间体导刊,2005(23):40-40.
-
7任晓兰,刘桂明.欧专局关于化合物多晶型专利的审查[J].中国发明与专利,2010(5):101-104. 被引量：1
-
8刘海燕.喝糖浆:4宜4不宜[J].父母必读,2009(7):44-44.
-
9吴俊威.取代型N-烷基化反应专利技术综述[J].精细化工中间体,2015,45(2):1-3. 被引量：4
-
10卜令雷,朱勇,王婧.高效液相色谱仪使用过程中的常见问题浅析[J].青年时代,2016,0(27):67-67. 被引量：1
