《史记·屈原贾生列传》作者祛疑

A Refutation against the Query on the Authorship of The Biographies of Qu Yuan and Jia Sheng in The Records of the Historian

汪春泓先生在《读〈史记.屈原贾生列传〉献疑》一文中提出《史记.屈原贾生列传》的作者是刘向,这一观点不能成立。汪文在论证过程中对很多文献资料的分析有误,从司马迁等人的"君臣观"、宣帝时代崇"文"贬"武"的思潮背景等内外因素进行的论证,也不足以证实刘向是《屈贾列传》的作者。

In his paper My Query： a Reaction to Reading The Biographies of Qu Yuan and Jia Sheng in The Records of the Historian, Mr. Wang Chunhong offered his doubt about the authorship of The Biographies of Qu Yuan and Jia Sheng, thinking that it should Liu Xiang. His point of view, however, cannot hold water. His paper makes misleading analyses of many documents and materials, collecting his bases by investigating such internal and exter- nal elements as Sima Qian and his like＇ s view of sovereign-subject relationship and the trend of advocating civil rather than military art in the reign of Emperor Wen. But all this fails to support the view that Liu Xiang was the au- thor of The Biographies of Qu Yuan and Jia Sheng.