批评的乏力与创新的缺失——与陈舒劼就中国当代文学“转向”问题商榷

An Argument Against Chen Shujie’s Literary Criticism from the Respective of Contemporary Literature “Turn”

陈舒劼在《石家庄学院学报》2013年第1期撰文《弄不清"转向"的批评》,就许玉庆在《文艺争鸣》上反驳张光芒关于中国当代文学"向外转"的文章作出批驳。令人遗憾的是,陈文因其批评立场的倾斜、理论分析上的"大而无当"和对理论创新认识的缺失等问题,导致其未能深入文学深层展开学理性分析,显现出批评的乏力和悖谬。

＂An Argument Against Xu Yuqing＇ s View of Contemporary Literature Turning＂ by Chen Shujie carried in Shijiazhuang University Journal （lst issue ,2013） refutes Xu Yuqing＇s article carried in Discussion of Liter- ature and Art. It is regrettable that Chen＇ s biased criticism stand, improper theoretic analysis and poor understanding of theoretic innovation result in his unreasonable analysis from literary depth, and weak and absurd criticism