王柏改定《大学》驳议

Did Wang Bai Ever Modify DaXue

宋儒王柏是学术史上一个颇受争议的代表人物,争议的焦点就在于王柏"奋笔而改经",其主要表现就是对《诗经》、《尚书》进行了大量的移易改动。清儒毛奇龄在《大学证文》中还认为王柏曾经改定过《大学》,列"王氏鲁斋改本"于"朱氏元晦改本"之后。王柏究竟有否改定过《大学》?文章认为,王柏改定《大学》的观点是不可信的。

Wang-Bai, a confucian of Song Dynasty, is one of the representatives that have ever been argued in the academic history. The focus of the dispute is that Wang-Bai modified the Classics of Confucianism courageously, such as Shi Jing and Shang Shu. Mao Qi- ling, a Confucian of Qing Dynasty, believed that Wang Bai once changed Da Xue, and listed that Lu Zhai Changed Text after Zhu-Xi＇ s. Has Wang Bai really modified DaXue7 This paper argues that the point of view ＂Wang Bai changed DaXue＂ is unbelievable.