形式合法性法治观及其中国语境

Formality Legitimacy on the Rule of Law and Its Chinese Context

学界对形式合法性法治观的研究,把握住了核心要点,但只是规定性的描述,而不是论证性的解释。借助温里布与帕森特从内在可理解性视角展开的法律理解争论,以"形式-质料会社会建构观"为分析框架对法律形式化问题进行研究,内在方面能够对形式主义作为法律的理性是什么予以描述,外在方面可以对形式法治作为法律之治的道理何在加以揭示。由此阐明,法治是法律自身固有的优点;形式法治提供给法律以效率的德性,在所达致的目标面前是中立的。恶法亦法问题并不与形式法治观有关联。

The study of formality legitimacy on the rule of law by academic community, is that only a description but rather than an explanation. With the discussion about law from internal comprehensibilityperspective by Ernest J. Weinrib and DennisM.Parcent, to study the problem of formalism of law by 'social constructionist view of form /material'can descript the rationality of law in internal aspect and explain the reason of formalism on the rule of law in external aspect. Thus it can be proved that rule of law is the inherent advantages of the law; formalism on the rule of law provides the virtue of efficiency and it is neutral when facing with the goal of State. Problem of evil law is not associated with such formalism on the rule of law.