基于论文数量、质量和持续性的专家遴选研究——以高等教育研究领域为例

Expert Selection Study Based on Quantity, Quality and Persistence of Theses——Taking higher education research as an example

在各个领域的评审中,专家评审是通行的方法,因此专家的筛选是一个重要的问题。高等教育研究领域的专家筛选,采用了基于研究者发表在该领域内核心期刊上的论文数量、质量和研究的持续性等指标方法。对2001-2011年中15种高等教育领域核心期刊中所刊载的33030篇文章,分为两个阶段进行分析,以筛选出符合条件的作者。两个阶段重合的作者,说明是在高等教育领域内持续的研究者,即为高等教育领域内的研究专家。然后,通过年龄上的遴选,得出高等教育领域内的青年专家。该筛选方法以新的角度,比较全面地解决了专家筛选的问题,并且具有较好的操作性。

Expert review is generally adopted in every domain; mus expert screen o ： Taking higher education research as an example, the essay studies the expert screen indicators, such as the number and the quality of the essays published on the core journals in the concerning domain, and the persistence of their research. The data quoted in the study originated from 33030 essays published on fifteen core journals in higher education during the years 2001-2011. We divide the duration into two periods： 2001-2005 and 2006-2011, and set separately the standards on essays＇ quantity and quality, we then screen the qualified authors. The names appear in both periods show the persistence of their study and prove their status as experts in the higher education domain. After this, we screen the rest of the authors in 2006-2011 on an age basis, and obtain the figure of young experts. The method solves the problem in expert screen from a new angle, thus provides a comprehensive solution with a high operability.