评刘宗昌等关于贝氏体铁素体形核的工作

Comment on Works Concerning the Nucleation of Bainitic Ferrite Authored by LIU Zongchang et al

评述了刘宗昌等关于贝氏体铁素体形核的工作,包括:(1)过少有关贝氏体铁素体形核机制文献综述;(2)实验工作远不够形核所要求的精确;(3)母相(奥氏体)中的成分和结构等起伏(涨落)不能成为贝氏体铁素体形核的基础;(4)提出的所谓"贝氏体形成属非切变非扩散机制"未得到先进相变理论和精细实验的支持。

Comment on works concerning the nucleation of bainitic ferrite, authored by Liu Zongchang et al, containing ： （ 1 ） few literature concerning nucleation mechanism of bainitic ferrite was cited ; （2） the experiments were far away from the required precision; （3） the composition and structural fluctuations in parent phase （austenite） can not effectively act as the nucleation of bainitic ferrite and （4） the suggested mechanism so called as ＂non-shear-diffusionless ＂ has not been supported by advanced theory of phase transformation or precise experimental result.