百余所师范院校及学报H指数的比较研究

Comparative study of 104 normal universities' H_U and H_J indexes

目的研究高等院校的H指数(H U)与其所办学报的H指数(H J)之间的相关性,为高校学报的管理和改革提供参考依据。方法通过CNKI中国引文数据库,对我国大陆地区104所师范院校及其所主办的高校学报进行检索统计,分析H U和H J之间的关联性。结果 2000年至2013年8月中旬的H指数比较结果显示,师范院校H U排序,北京师范大学名列榜首,H U=66,其次是华东师范大学,H U=60,南京师范大学排名第三,H U=50。主办的53种自然科学版高校学报H指数(H J-N S)排序结果,《西南师范大学学报:自然科学版》名列第一,H J-N S=38;《首都师范大学学报:自然科学版》名列第二,H J-N S=37;《北京师范大学学报:自然科学版》排名第三,H J-N S=35。社会科学版学报的H指数(HJ-S S)排序,《北京师范大学学报:哲学社会科学版》遥遥领先,H J-S S=71;《华中师范大学学报:人文社会科学版》名列第二,H J-S S=56;《南京师大学报:社会科学版》和《西南师范大学学报:哲学社会科学版》为并列第三,H J-S S=50。104所师范院校H U与H J之间具有一定的相关性,具体关系式为H J=9.399+0.595 HU,其线性相关系数R2=0.673 1。结论高校学报的H指数(H J)与主办院校的H指数(H U)之间存在一定的相关性,高校学报水平受制于主办院校学术水平的高低,主办院校H U越高,则主办的高校学报H J则越高,否则相反。

Objective--To study the relationship between the H index （Hv） of universities and the H index （Hj） of the journals published by them, and provide a reference for the management and reform of the university journals in the future. Methods--CNKI Chinese Citation Database was used to retrieve H indexes （Hu and Hj） of 104 normal universities in China's Mainland, then the relationship between Hv and Hj was studied by analyzing the H index （Hu） of universities and the H index （Hj） of their journal（s）. Results--The comparison results of H indexes from year 2000 to mid-august in 2013 show that normal universities＇ Hu ranks as follows： Beijing Normal University ranked first, Hu = 66, followed by East China Normal University, Hu = 60, Nanjing Normal University ranked third, Hu =50. The ranking result of the H index （Hj Ns） of 53 natural science journals sponsored by normal universities is that Journal of Southwest Normal University （Natural Science Edition） ranked first, HiEs=38; Journal of Capital Normal University （Natural Science Edition） ranked second, HjNS = 37; Journal of Beijing Normal University （Natural Science Edition） ranked third, HjNs =35. The ranking result of the H index （Hj ss） for journal of social science edition, the first was Journal of Beijing Normal University （Philosophy and Social Science Edition）, its Hsss ~ 71; Journal of Central China Normal University （Humanities and Social Science Edition） ranked second, Hjss----- 56; Journal of Nanjing Normal University （Social Science Edition） and Journal of Southwest Normal University （Philosophy and Social Science Edition） tied for third place, Hj-ss=50. The rela- tionship between H1 and Hu of 104 normal colleges and universities was given as follows. Hj-ss =9. 399 ＋0. 595Hu, its linear correlation coefficient is R2 = 0. 673 1. Conclusion--There is a correlation between Hj and Hu, the level of university journals is subjected to the academic level of its publishing institutions, the higher Hu is, the higher Hj is. Otherwise it is opposite.