范长江“研究红军北上以后中国的动向”目的论析

An Analysis to Fan Changjiang's Journalistic Purpose in "China's Tendency after the Red Army's Marching North"

范长江西北采访是否存在"研究红军北上以后中国的动向"的目的,学术界一直存在着两种截然相反的不同意见。争论关系到对范长江红军长征报道的评价问题。在范长江的西北采访所形成的新闻文本中,有大量的对其新闻目的直接表述的文字,足证这一新闻目的的存在。否定论者提出的几个论据及其论证,都缺少推翻这一新闻目的存在的说服力。

There are two controversial opinions in the academic circle, concerning if there exists a journalistic purpose of stud- ying ＂China＇ s Tendency after the Red Army＇ s Marching North＂ in Fan Changjiang＇ s interviews in northwest China. This debate concerns how to evaluate Fan Changjiang＇ s reports on the Red Army＇ s Long March. In Fan＇ s journalistic texts based on his in- terviews in northwest China, there are abundant direct mentions of his journalistic purpose, which well justifies its own existence. It is short of convincing power in the denial arguments and their corresponding proofs provided by refuting scholars.