论刑事司法政策的批判特性

The Criticism of Criminal Justice Policy

刑事司法政策的批判性源自公共政策批判理论。不管是作为一种公共精神还是作为一种方法论,公共政策批判都为公共理性在公共福利的追求中保留了相当的地位。根据公共政策批判理论,刑事司法政策批判,不仅主张多元的刑事司法利益,而且将多元、普遍的刑事司法批判作为刑事司法民主、进步的标志。因此,现在的刑事司法政策研究(包括宽严相济的刑事政策),仍然存在突出的批判不足问题。尤其是风起云涌的群众司法批判经常越界,这应当受到法律知识和法治原则的严格规制。

The criticism of criminal justice policy comes from the critical theory of public policy. Whether as a public spirit or a kind of methodology, criticism of public policy has always had a place for public rationality in public welfare pursuit. According to the theory of public policy criticism, the criticism of criminal justice policy not only proposes multiple judicial interests, but also im- proves multiple and universal critical justice policy as a mark of democracy and progress of criminal justice. However, the study of criminal justice policy （including the criminal policy of punishment with leniency） has its shortcomings in critical inadequacy. Obvi- ously, the criticism of justice among the mass is often beyond the mark, which should be strictly regulated by legal knowledge and the principle of rule of law.