数字出版时代学术论文的互动评价探索

Discussion on interactive evaluation of academic papers in the digital publishing era

针对目前学术论文评价体系中仅有专家评价以及使用计量学指标进行评价、缺少读者意见的现状,提出在现有评价体系的基础上增加读者评价的互动评价机制。学术论文的互动评价可以明确读者的主体地位,增强作者的存在感,改变学术信息单向传播的现状,打破论文评价中少数人的垄断地位,体现出对信息传播规律的尊重。数字出版建立在高度互动的互联网媒体平台上,使互动评价的实施变得简单、容易。在现有评价体系的基础上,建立科学的具有读者反馈功能的互动评价机制,可以促进学术交流,丰富并完善现有的学术论文评价体系。

In current academic papers evaluation system, the evaluation only considering peer review and bibliometric indexes but ignoring readers＇ comments is not sufficient. It is necessary to introduce readers＇ comments into the evaluation system to construct an interactive evaluation mechanism of academic papers. The interactive evaluation may identify reader＇s predominant status, enhance writer＇s attractive sense, change the present one-way propagation of academic information, break the defect of the current evaluation system that depends on only a few persons, and show observance to the principle of information communication. The digital publication is based on highly interactive internet media platform, so implementation of the interactive evaluation becomes simple and easy. Based on the existing evaluation system, an interactive evaluation mechanism with readers＇ feedback can be established to promote academic exchange, enrich and improve the existing evaluation system of academic papers.