文学史的写作类型与文本性质——论刘大杰《中国文学发展史》的三次修订

WRITING TYPES OF LITERATURE HISTORY AND CHARACTER OF TEXT ——ON THREE REVISIONS OF LIU DA-JIE'S <THE DEVELOPMENT HISTORY OF CHINESE LITERATURE>

通过对刘大杰《中国文学发展史》原本与三次修订本之间的比较研究 ,首先分析了两种文学史的写作类型——学术专著型和教科书型的特点 ,以及刘著文学史的写作类型的变化 ;其次分析了三次修订带来的另一种变化——文本性质的变化 ,由此探讨了人文性叙述文本的特性 ,暗示了阐释性观念在叙述历史中的作用的限度 。

Through the comparison of the primary and the three revised editions of LIU Da jies <The Development History of Chinese Literature>,the arthor first analyzes the features of the two writing types of literature history-the type of academic work and of textbook,and the changes of the writing styles in the revisions.In the second part,she investigates another change that results from the revisions:the change of the character of text;inquires into the character of the narration text of the humanities;and suggests the possible harmfulness if beyond the limitation of the effects that the interpretative concepts have on the writing of history.