审稿项目对审稿质量的影响

Influence of peer reviewing items on reviewing quality

采用 3种不同类型的审稿项目 ,进行审稿质量实验。结果表明 :审稿项目建立得越全面、科学 ,审稿质量越高 ;反之 ,审稿项目建立得越简单粗糙 ,审稿质量则越低。建立了化学化工类稿件的审稿项目 。

Test on reviewing quality by adopting three different typ es of items shows that the more comprehensive and scientific the reviewing items are, the higher reviewing quality we will obtain. On the contrary, th e simpler and coarser the items are, the lower quality will he obtaine d. Meanwhile, a list of reviewing items for chemistry and chemical engineering papers is developed in this circle for reference.