期刊文献+

科学文献数据库中撤销论文分布规律研究——以Web of Science数据库为例 被引量:13

The Distribution of Retracted Articles in Scientific Literature Database
下载PDF
导出
摘要 随着撤销论文数量地不断增加,科学文献数据库对撤销论文标注地日益规范以及学术界对撤销论文现象地逐步重视,相关研究越来越多。本文以Web of Science数据库中撤销论文数据为研究对象,从年份、学科、国家、期刊、机构及作者等6个方面对撤销论文的分布规律及特点进行分析总结。以期在揭示国际科学文献数据库中撤销论文分布特点的同时,提高我国科研管理部门、文献数据库商、期刊编辑和科研人员等对撤销论文及其不良影响的关注,进一步规范对撤销论文的标注。促进学术期刊出版机构及科研管理部门建立健全相应的管理机制,制定行之有效的管理措施,遏制我国学术不端行为的发生。 With the increasing number of retracted articles, and the standard development of retracted article's label indexed by journal database, as well as the attention to retraction phenomenon from academic community, there are more and more researches about retracted articles. In this paper, we used the data about retracted articles from Web of Science, and summarized laws and characteristics of retracted articles from aspects of year, subject field, national, journal, institution and author. We hope to reveal the characteristics of retracted articles all over the world, and improve the attention to retracted articles and their influence from government institutions, journal publishers, editors and researchers. And help them to establish management mechanisms and regulations to restrain the occurrence of scientific misconduct.
出处 《情报学报》 CSSCI 北大核心 2014年第4期375-387,共13页 Journal of the China Society for Scientific and Technical Information
关键词 科学文献数据库 撤销论文 分布规律 学术不端 科研管理 scientific literature database, retracted article, distribution law, scientific misconduct, researchmanagement
  • 相关文献

参考文献32

  • 1National Science Fonudation. Research Misconduct [ J ]. Federal Register, 2002, 67 ( 17 ) :3666-3669.
  • 2Article withdrawal [ OL ]. [ 2013-10-21 ]. http ://www. elsevier, com/about/publishing-guidelines/policies/ article- withdrawal#Article -retraction.
  • 3Publishing ethics and other policies [ OL ]. [ 2014-03- 16 ]. http ://royalsocietypublishing. org/ethics-and-policy #question4.
  • 4Errata, Retractions, Partial Retractions, Corrected and Republished Articles, Duplicate Publications, Comments ( including Author Replies) , Updates, Patient Summaries, and Republished ( Reprinted ) Articles Policy for MEDLINE? [ OL ]. [ 2013-10-21 ]. http://www, nlm. nih. gov/pubs/factsheets/ errata, html#retractions.
  • 5Guidelines for retracting articles [ OL]. [ 2013-09-28 ]. http://publicationethics, org/ resources/guidelines.
  • 6Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals: Publishing and Editorial Issues Related to Publication in Medical Journals: Scientific Misconduct, Expressions of Concern, and Retraction [ OL ]. [ 2013-10-21 ]. http :// www. icmje, org/publishing_b, html.
  • 7Correction and retraction policy [ OL]. [ 2013-10-21 ]. http://www, nature, corn/ authors/policies/ corrections. html.
  • 8PLOS Editorial and Publishing Policies [OL]. [ 2013-10- 15]. http://www, plosone, org/static/ policies, action# reporting.
  • 9Scientific misconduct[ OL]. [ 2014-04-10 ]. http ://www. bmj. com/about-bmj/resources-authors/ forms-policies- and- checklists/scientific-misconduct.
  • 10Corrections and Retraction Policy- Edorium Journals [ OL ]. [ 2013-10-21 ]. http ://www. edoriumjournals. com/corrections-retractions-articles-edorium-joumals, php.

二级参考文献104

  • 1关于加强科研行为规范建设的意见[J].中国科技期刊研究,2007,18(2):204-205. 被引量:24
  • 2National Library of Medicine. Fact sheet. Errata, retractions, partial retractions, corrected and republished articles, duplicatepublications, comments ( including author replies), updates, patient summaries, and republished (reprinted) articles policy for MEDLINE ( updated 04/06/2010). [ 2011-02-11 ]. http ://www. nlm. nih. gov/pubs/factsheets/errata, html.
  • 3[ 2011-03-02 ]. http ://www. nature, corn/nature/authors.
  • 4ACS. Ethical Guidelines to Publication of Chemical Research. [ 2011-03-02 ]. http ://pubs. acs. org/instructYethic, html.
  • 5Anne Victoria Neale, Justin Northrup, Rhonda Dailey, Ellen Marks, Judith Abrams. Correction and use of biomedical literature affected by scientific misconduct. Science and Engineering Ethics, 2007. 13 : 5 - 24.
  • 6Murat Cokol, Fath Ozbay. Retraction rates are on the rise. EMBO reports, 2008, 9 ( 1 ) : 2.
  • 7Murat Cokol, et al. How many scientific papers should be retracted? EMBO reports, 2007, 8 (5) : 422 -423.
  • 8Larry D Claxton. Scientific authorship Part 1. A window into scientific fraud.'? Mutation Research, 2005, 589 (1) : 17 -30.
  • 9http ://www. sciencedirect, corn/.
  • 10Elsevier Policy on Article Withdrawal. [ 2011-03-02 1. http:// elsevier, comZwps/find/intro, cws _ home/ Article% 20Withdrawal.

共引文献95

同被引文献137

  • 1孙岳,张红伟.我国中文期刊撤稿因素交叉分析及对策研究[J].编辑学报,2021,33(5):533-538. 被引量:11
  • 2梁春阳.《哲学研究》引文分析[J].图书馆理论与实践,1989(3):11-15. 被引量:2
  • 3Steen RG. Retractions in the scientific literature : do authorsdeliberately commit research fraud. [ J]. 7 Med Ethics, 20 \ 1,37(2) :113 -117.
  • 4Balhara YPS, Mishra A. Compliance of retraction notices forretracted articles on mental disorders with COPE guidelines onretraction[ J]. Current Science,2014,107(5) :757 -760.
  • 5Wager E,Williams P. Why and how do journals retract articles.An analysis of Medline retractions 1988-2008 [ J ]. / MedEthics{9) : 567 -570.
  • 6Gasparyan AY, Ayvazyan L, Akazhanov NA, et al. Self-correction in biomedical publications and the scientific impact[i]. Croat Med J ,2011 ,55(1) x 61 -72.
  • 7Steen RG, Casadevall A, Fang FC. Why has the number ofscientific retractions increased. [ J ]. PLoS One,2013,8(7):e68397.
  • 8Fang FC, Casadevall A. Retracted science and the retractionindex[J]. Infect Immun,2011 ,79(10) : 3855 -3859.
  • 9Madlock-Brown CR, Eichmann D. The (lack of) impact ofretraction citation networks [ J]. Sci Eng Ethics ,2015,21(1):127 -137.
  • 10Singh HP, Mahendra A, Yadav B, et al. A comprehensiveanalysis of articles retracted between 2004 and 2013 frombiomedical literature-a call for reforms[ J]. J Tradit ComplementM^,2014,4(3) :136 -139.

引证文献13

二级引证文献79

相关作者

内容加载中请稍等...

相关机构

内容加载中请稍等...

相关主题

内容加载中请稍等...

浏览历史

内容加载中请稍等...
;
使用帮助 返回顶部