柴窑“出北地”问题论辩

On the Issue of Cai Kiln in the Northern Area

本文通过对柴窑"出北地"、"出北地河南郑州"等文献尤其是版本诸多问题的讨论,认为"河南郑州"既有可能是曹昭《格古要论》的原文,也有可能是云间舒敏志学等人增加的,认为仅可能是王佐增加的观点是可商榷的;同时认为柴窑"出北地河南郑州"这一说法具有一定的可信性,并倾向于认为今郑州很可能是柴窑一个重要的接近京畿的烧造地。

The article, discussing various document versions such as Chai kiln in the north, in the north of Zhengzhou Henan and so on, considers that in Zhengzhou Henan may be recorded by Ge Gu Yao Lun written by Cao Zhao or may be added by Shu Min from Yunjian, but the point of view was arguable that it was added by Wang Zuo. This article considers that the argument of the Chai Kiln in the North of Zheng Zhou Henan is credible certainly and Zhengzhou is an important firing place for Chai Kiln closing to the capital of the Song Dynasty.