《塔林网络战国际法手册》的网络主权观评介

Cyber Sovereignty Concept of Tallinn Manual on the International Law Applicable to Cyber War Review

主权问题是网络空间安全法的一个基础性问题。北约卓越合作网络防御中心适用于网络战的国际法典《塔林手册》开篇即对网络空间安全的"主权"问题和国家责任问题作了规定和阐述。鉴于手册是目前关于网络战的法律方面的最重要的文献之一,手册对网络战适用国际法的理论基础——主权的论述会产生较大的国际影响。探讨手册中网络主权的界定、主权的内容和主权下的国家责任内容,对其存在的范围狭窄和逻辑缺陷,主要概念含混等问题作了深入的剖析。

Sovereignty is a basic problem in cyberspace security law. From the beginning, the NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence~ Tallinn Manual provides the ＂sovereignty＇＇ and the responsibility of the state . The manual is currently on the legal aspects of cyber warfare is one of the most important literature, Manual of theory Based on the sovereignty of cyber warfare application of international law discussion will have international influence. This paper probes into the cyberspace sovereignty manual definition, contents and sovereign under state responsibility, in-depth analysis of the scope of the existing narrow, logical flaws, and the main vague concepts.