认真对待人身危险性评估

Taking Evaluation of Personal Fatalness Seriously

人身危险性的评估问题是人身危险性理论得以实践运转和功能发挥的现实前提。对人身危险性评估的长期忽视是对人身危险性客观实体的误读,其主观裁断的结论得出与理性判断不具同一性,司法资源的节约也不是否定其科学评估的实质理由,而且感性判断的表面趋附将把人身危险性理论引向歧途。因此,我们应该慎重对待人身危险性评估,通过建立规范化的评估规则与程序细则来矫正现有操作模式中存在的诸多弊端。认真对待人身危险性评估,必须以发掘人身危险性理论的内在价值为目标,探究符合刑罚理论且有实践可操作性的新路径,摆脱依赖感性判断所带来的随意性与非科学性误区。

The evaluation of personal fatalness is the prerequisite of the personal fatalness theory＇ s operation. Owing to misunderstanding of objective entity, lack of theoretical judgment, unorthodox i- dea of saving resource and result to crossroad by way of emotional judgment, it is better to evaluate personal fatalness with prudence, and set up standardized evaluation rules to adjust the problems in the operation. Careful treatment to evaluation of personal fatalness requires exploring the instinct value of the theory of personal fatalness, probing into the new practical method which also matches the principle of criminal and punishment theory, getting rid of the casual and non - scientific misunderstanding brought by perceptual judgment.