刑事司法对刑法规范的价值判断——从“实名制下替人购火车票案”谈起

Criminal Judicial to Value Judgment of Criminal Law Norms——Based on “Buying Tickets for Others in the Real-name System” Cases

刑事司法是对刑法规范的一种价值判断活动。在实践中,刑事司法对刑法规范的价值判断所表现出的绝对形式主义必将自身引向一条"不归路"。基于现代法治理念,刑事司法应当是一种对刑法规范进行的合立法目的性、合情理性、合必要性和合逻辑性价值判断活动。

The criminal judicial is an activity of value judgment of criminal law norms. In the criminal judicial activity, absolute formalism will lead it to the point of no return. Based on the modern concept of rule of law, the criminal judicial＇to value judgment of criminal law norms should comply with the legislative purpose, reasonable, necessity and logicality.