顾实与姚明辉《汉书·艺文志》研究刍议

Discussion about Gu Shi's and Yao Ming-hui's Research on Bibliography·Book of Han

《汉书·艺文志》是中国现存最早的史志目录,对后世的图书分类影响深远。姚明辉《汉书艺文志注解》与顾实《汉书艺文志讲疏》是近代注解《汉书·艺文志》的代表性著作。两者对《汉书·艺文志》都采用标注存亡的方法,但对待章学诚"互著法"态度不同,古籍注解内容颇有殊异。对两家著作进行比较分析,是为深入研究两者学术价值的基础性工作之一。

Bibliography·Book of Hanis the earliest catalogue of biographical history,political literature and local annals in China,and it has a far-reaching influence on the book classification of later generations.Gu Shi＇s Commentaries on Bibliography·Book of Han and Yao Ming-hui＇s Annotation of Bibliography·Book of Han are the representative works in modern times.They both used the methods of marking＂existing or lost＂,but showed different attitudes towards Zhang Xue-cheng＇s method of＂Reciprocal Record＂.The paper thinks that the comparative analysis of these two books is one of the groundwork to further study their academic value.