期刊文献+

论证据学的学科定位 被引量:2

Disciplinary Orientation of Evidence Science
原文传递
导出
摘要 神示证据制度后,西方国家选择的基本证据制度就是法定证据制度。法定证据制度的本质就是法律制约证据,这就是历代立法中犯下的最大错误。这一错误颠倒了意识和存在的关系、践踏了证据的客观属性、把证据问题人为地变成了法律问题。证据学研究证据及其规律,而证据及其规律都是事实问题,不是法律问题;证据学研究证明及其规则,而证明及其规则都是认识问题,也不是法律问题。由此来看,证据学根本不是法学。证据学是着重从实质层面研究证明的学问。逻辑学是从形式层面研究证明的学问,被称为"形式逻辑"。证据学就应称为"实质逻辑"。"实质逻辑"就是证据学的学科定位。 After abandoning the system of divinity evidence, western countries have chosen the system of legal evidence as their basic evidence system. Taking the restriction of evidence by law as the essence of the system of legal evidence has been the biggest mistake made in legislation throughout the history. This understanding confuses the relationship between consciousness and existence, tramples upon the objective attribute of evidence, and artificially turns the issue of evidence into a legal issue. Evidence science studies evidence and its objective law, both of which are questions of fact, the rules on proof, both which are questions rather than questions of law. It studies proof and of cognition, rather than questions of law. Therefore evidence science is not law science at all. It is a science that studies proof at the substantive level whereas logics is a science that studies proof at the formal level and is call "formal logics". Evidence science should be called "substantive logics" and sub tantive logics shouldbe the disciplinary orientation of evidence science.
作者 裴苍龄
机构地区 西北政法大学
出处 《环球法律评论》 CSSCI 北大核心 2015年第1期5-19,共15页 Global Law Review
  • 相关文献

参考文献5

  • 1毛泽东.《星星之火,可以燎原》,载《毛泽东选集》(一卷本),人民出版社,1966年版,第96页.
  • 2江伟,吴泽勇.《证据若干基本问题的法哲学分析》,载法苑精萃编辑委员会,编.《中国诉讼法学精萃》(2003年卷),机械工业出版社,2004年版,第136页.
  • 3赵成泽,黄金波.《自由心证是程序公正的终点站-关于自由心证问题研究的理念式大纲》,载《证据学论坛》(第六卷),中国检察出版社,2003年版,第437页.
  • 4汪建成,孙远.《自由心证新论-自由心证之自由与不自由》,载《证据学论坛》(第一卷),中国检察出版社,2000年版,第335页.
  • 5杨宇冠.论非法证据排除规则的价值[J].政法论坛,2002,20(3):111-118. 被引量:39

二级参考文献12

  • 1[意]贝卡里亚 黄风.论犯罪与刑罚[M].北京:中国大百科全书出版社,1993..
  • 2Bivens v. Six Unknown Named Agents of Federal Bureau of Narcotics, 403 U.S. 388, 415 (1971).
  • 3Stone,500 (Chief Justice Burger concurring).
  • 4Mr. Justice Clark, Mapp v Ohio, 367. U.S. 643 (1961).
  • 5United States v. Peliter, 422 U.S. 531,554 (1975) (Justice Brennan dissenting).
  • 6Charles F. Hemphill, Jr. Criminal Procedure, Goodyear Publishing Co. , Inc 1978.
  • 7Peopler. Defore, 160N. E. (1926) P. 578.
  • 8Calandra, 347,1974.
  • 9Wolf: A Survey of the Expanded Exclusionary Rule, 32 Geo. Wash. L. Rev. 193, 216 (1963).
  • 10The criminal goes free, if he must, but it is the law that sets him free. Nothing can destroy a government more quickly than its failure to observe its own laws, or worse, its disregard of the charter of its own existence. 367 U.S. at 659.

共引文献38

同被引文献63

  • 1卞建林,张璐.“排除合理怀疑”之理解与适用[J].国家检察官学院学报,2015,23(1):93-101. 被引量:43
  • 2朱孝清.检察官负有客观义务的缘由[J].国家检察官学院学报,2015,23(3):14-20. 被引量:16
  • 3Chen Weidong,Li Xiang.On Interested Parties in Special Confiscation Procedures for Illegal Income. Tribune of Political Science and Law . 2015
  • 4Zuo Weimin.'Hot'and'Cold':An Empirical Study on the Application of Exclusionary Rule. Studies in Law and Business . 2015
  • 5Chen Yongsheng.On the Causes of Misjudged Criminal Cases. Peking University Law Journal . 2015
  • 6Jin Zegang.Causes and Prevention of Judges’’Misjudgment:Based on Sample Analysis of 19 Misjudged Criminal Cases. Law Review . 2015
  • 7Wang Jiancheng.On Evidence-based Adjudication and Prevention of Misjudged Cases:Based on Analysis of 16 Msjudged Criminal Cases. Peking University Law Journal . 2015
  • 8Zuo Weimin.An Empirical Study on the Financial System of the Basic Level Courts in China. China Legal Science . 2015
  • 9Yang Yuguan,Guo Xu.Discussion on the Application of the Standard of Proof of'Beyond a Reasonable Doubt'in China. Law Science . 2015
  • 10Gu Yongzhong,Yang Jianwei.Status quo of the Implementation of Criminal Legal Aid in China and Countermeasures:Based on the Investigation and Reflection on the Implementation of the Criminal Procedure Law of 2013. Law Science . 2015

引证文献2

二级引证文献2

相关作者

内容加载中请稍等...

相关机构

内容加载中请稍等...

相关主题

内容加载中请稍等...

浏览历史

内容加载中请稍等...
;
使用帮助 返回顶部