《词源》卷上是伪托之书——元起善斋抄本《词源》卷上真伪考

The Volume One of Ci YuanIs a Forged Book——Distinguishing The Volume One of Qi Shan Zhai Handwritten Copy of Yuan Dynasty to The Original Book

通过考察二卷本《词源》的流传著录情况及比对今传元起善斋抄本《词源》与《事林广记》等类书的关系,认为关于词曲音乐资料的所谓《词源》卷上非张炎原书,而是后人通过对《事林广记》等类书的过录节抄,置于张炎《词源》之上的伪托之作。二卷本《词源》卷下乃张炎《词源》原书。

By studying the hand dow n net of Ci Y uan and comparing the Qi Shan Zhai handw ritten copy with Shi Lin Ghuang Ji and so on ,this paper points out that the volume one of Ci Yuan which is about the music data is a forged book .The volume one was not written by Zhang Yan ,but forged by the other per‐son on the basis of Shi Lin Guang Ji and so on .The volume two is the original book written by Zhang Yan .