网络有偿删帖发帖的入罪反思——以“立二拆四”非法经营案为切入点

The Review of Criminalization of Deleting and Publishing Internet Information——From the Case of “Li Er Chai Si” Illegal Business Operations

非法经营罪自设立以来,司法解释对其进行过数次扩张,实践中绕过该罪条文及相关司法解释而直接以非法经营罪定罪的案例层出不穷,非法经营罪堵截条款的防线有被突破的嫌疑。近期,司法解释将有偿删帖发帖行为规定为非法经营罪,这一方面不符合非法经营罪的罪质特征,另一方面也违背了刑法体系解释的解释原理。通过不断扩充非法经营罪的司法解释来规制实践中花样翻新的违法经营行为,这使得非法经营罪的口袋化基因愈发明显,非法经营罪的口袋化趋势急需遏制。

Since theestablishment of the crime of illegal business operations,judicial interpretations have expanded it several times and courts are frequent inconvicting people of the crime directly regardless of the article and relevant judicial interpretation,and therefore,the preventing article of the crime of illegal business operations is suspected of being broken through. Moreover,in recent years,judicial interpretation have ruled the paid service of deleting and publishing the internet informationas the crime of illegal business operations,whichon one hand does not comply with the characteristics of this crime,on the other hand goes against the principle of systematic interpretation. If we deal with the various illegal business operations only through continously expanding the relevent judicial interpretations,the pockets trend of the crime will keep going. That ＇s what we should do now—to stop the pockets trend.