《经义考·通说》引文考辨十二则

Arguments for Twelve Essays in the Introduction to Jing Yi Kao Tong Shuo

朱彝尊《经义考·通说》四卷,辑录历代关于经学评论的文字四百余则,均未注明详细出处,且引文多经其剪裁。后代学者不明《经义考·通说》引文原始出处,据以征引时,无从覆案原文,以致时有谬误产生。本文考辨《经义考·通说》十二则引文的出处,期于增加学界转引《经义考·通说》相关材料时的真实性和准确性。间附辑录朱彝尊佚文《两汉精华跋》,并考订出何洛文、刘曰宁二人的生卒年。

＂Jing Yi Kao Tong Shuo＂ by Zhu Yizun, consisting of four volumes, is a collection of criticisms of Confucian classics in the past dynasties. Without exact footnotes of the sources and pruned a lot in addition, it makes the later scholars impossible to know the original provenance and inevitably make mistakes when quoting from Jing Yi Kao Tong Shuo. Therefore, the arguments of this paper wiU help to ensure the authenticity and preciseness of the quotations to discover the sources of the quoted essays. It attempts to research the sources of ten quoted essays in Jing Yi Kao Tong Shuo to reduce the mistakes in the course of secondary quoting and, meanwhile , find one article unprinted in the complete works of ZhuYizun, making clear the birth and death dates of He Luowen and Liu Yuening.