“以类相从”与“见微知著”——关于两部中古赋史的比较

History of Fu in Wei,Jin,Northern and Southern Dynasties and History of Fu in Six Dynasties: a Comparison

程章灿《魏晋南北朝赋史》与王琳《六朝辞赋史》是研究魏晋南北朝辞赋史的两部巨著,程著注重辞赋的类型化分析,王著则以作家作品分析见长,二书在叙述视角、叙述方法、行文结构上存在一些差异,但在书写过程中,二书亦有许多相似之处,如广博宏富的学术视角、客观的写史态度等。二书的论述,能够形成互补态势,为我们了解魏晋南北朝时期的赋史全貌奠定基础。

Both Cheng Zhangchan ’ s History of Fu in Wei, Jin, Northern and Southern Dynasties and Wang Lin’s History of Fu in Six Dynasties are great works of studying the history of Fu in Wei, Jin, Northern and South-ern Dynasties.Cheng’s book focuses the categorization analysis , while Wang’s book is good at the analysis of the writers and works .The two books are different in narrative perspective , narrative methods and writing style .Never-theless, they are much similarities such as the extensive academic perspective and objective history -writing atti-tude.Complementarily , these two books lay a foundation for us to understand the complete picture of Fu history in the Dynasties .