从移民传说到地域认同:明清国家的形成被引量：34

From the “Immigrant Stories”to Regional Identity: The Formation of the Ming-Qing States

下载PDF

导出

摘要近年来不同学科对认同问题的讨论很多,但在历史学内部,较为引人注意的是与美国"新清史"有关的讨论,以及美国《近代中国》"华琛专号"引发的讨论,这些讨论是与海内外中国研究对多元性的重视及对大一统机制的探讨直接相关的。移民传说是讨论地域认同的一个切入点,它是16—18世纪地域认同不断扩展,也即明清国家形成的重要表征。无论是对认同问题的讨论,还是对明清国家形成的认识,都应被置于一个具体的历史情境和时空过程中。 There have been heated discussions around the topic of identity in different disciplines in recent years. Concerning the study of history,particular attention has been paid to the discussion on'new History of the Qing Dynasty',as well as the dispute on the special issue of James Watson in the America-based Modern China,which are directly related to the stress on the diversification and the inquiries into the mechanism of unification in the China studies at home and aboard. The immigrant stories could be a break through point for the discussion on the regional identity. They were important representation of the development of regional identity,namely,the formation of Ming-Qing states from the 16th to 18th centuries. However,both the discussion on identity and the analysis of the formation of Ming-Qing states should be put in a concrete historical context and a spatio-temporal process.

作者赵世瑜

机构地区北京大学历史系

出处《华东师范大学学报（哲学社会科学版）》 CSSCI 北大核心 2015年第4期1-10,167,共10页 Journal of East China Normal University（Humanities and Social Sciences）

基金香港中文大学科大卫教授主持之卓越领域计划(AoE)项目"中国社会的历史人类学研究"的阶段性成果之一

关键词移民传说地域认同明清国家形成 “新清史” “华琛专号” immigrant stories,regional identity,formation of Ming-Qing States,new History of the Qing Dynasty,special issue of James Watson

分类号 K248 [历史地理—中国史]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献27

1刘风云、董建中、刘文鹏编:《清代政治与国家认同》,北京:社会科学文献出版社,2012年.
2欧立德:《满文档案与“新清史”》,刘风云、刘文鹏编:《清朝的国家认同——“新清史”研究与争鸣》,第391页.
3黄兴涛:《清朝满人的"中国认同"--对美国"新清史"的一种回应》,刘风云、董建中、刘文鹏编:《清代政治与国家认同》,第16-34页.
4James Watson, "Standardizing the Gods : The Promotion of T'ien Hou ( ' Empress of Heaven' ) Along the South China Coast, 960-- 1960", in David Johnson, Andrew Nathan, and Evelyn Rawski ed., Popular Culture in Late Imperial China, pp.292-324. University of California Press, 1985.
5Modem China, 33:1 (2007), pp.3-153.
6《历史人类学学刊》第6卷,第1—2期合刊,2008年.
7苏堂栋:《明清时期的文化一体性、差异性与国家——对标准化与正统实践的讨论之延伸》;科大卫、刘志伟:《简短的回应》,《历史人类学学刊》第7卷第2期,2009年,第139—166页.
8Empire at the Margins: Culture, Ethnicity, and Frontier in Early Modern China, P.Crossley, H.Siu, and D.Sutton ed., University of Cal- ifornia Press, 2006.
9刘风云、刘文鹏编:《清朝的国家认同——“新清史”研究与争鸣》,第93—128页.
10P.K.Crossley, "Making Mongols", in Empire at the Margins: Culture, Ethnicity, and Frontier in Early Modern China, P.Crossley, H. Siu, and I).Sutton ed., pp.58-82, University of California Press, 2006.