《宋代诗歌总集新考》献疑

Queries on “New Examination of the Collection of the Song Dynasty's Poems

卞东波《宋代诗歌总集新考》一文在考证内容上有值得商榷的地方,具体而言,卞氏所考《唐宋类诗》、《郴江前集》《后集》《续集》为重复辑考,祝尚书《宋人总集叙录》已考证,并非新考;《润州类集》、《滁州集》著录名称不妥,应为《丹阳类稿》、《滁阳庆历集》,且后者为《宋人总集叙录》已考,亦非新考;《蕙亩拾英集》的性质是诗话,而非诗歌总集。

Bian Dongbo＇ s ＂New Examination of the Collection of the Song Dynasty＇ s Poems is worth critiquing in contents. Specifically, his examination of ＂Poems of the Tang and Song Dynasties＂ and ＂Book 1, Book 2 and Continued Part of Chenjiang＂ is not new but a duplicated effort over previous work. Besides, there are similar problems elsewhere and even a problem of identifying literary genres.