“头炷香”可拍卖性的法学分析——兼谈特殊标的拍卖的监管回应

Legal Analysis of the Permissiveness of Auction of“First Incense”——A Concurrent Discussion of the Regulatory Response on the Special Auction Object

特殊标的拍卖及其监管涉及诸多法律问题,"头炷香"拍卖即是其例。进头香之机会属于稀缺资源,符合财产权的基本要件。拍卖"头炷香"尚未引发现实的权利冲突,属于宗教领域的经营行为,依照宗教自治原则应予必要尊重。特殊标的拍卖是一个尤待论证并亟须监管回应的重要问题,其法学论证往往不限于拍卖法、市场监管法的指涉范围。

The special auction object and it＇s supervision involve many legal issues, and the auction of ＂first incense＂ is an example. ＂First incense＂ is a scarce resource and belongs to property right. The auction of ＂first incense＂ has not resulted in right conflicts in reality and belongs to the marketing behavior in the field of religion. It should be respected according to the principle of religious self-government. The special object＇s auction is an important problem which still needs to be demonstrated and responded by the regulation system. It＇s legal argumentation should not be confined to the auction law and the market regulation law.