“集体选用稿”在高校学报稿件“三审制”中的运用

Application of “collective-selected draft” in the “Triple-Draft System” in the Journal of universities

"集体选用稿"制度可缩短高校学报的审稿时滞,纠正审稿偏倚现象,达到基本退稿率要求,确保稿件质量,吸纳优质稿件。在"三审制"实施过程中,初审和外审的局限性、审稿时滞周期长、审稿环节的偏倚现象对选用稿存在一定的影响。根据集体选用稿的准确有效原则、公开公正原则、及时性原则、平等性原则及"择优选用"原则,制定了确定评判标准、整体审读、专篇审读讨论、确定录用稿件及提出修改意见的集体选用稿实施方式。集体选用稿的实施,有利于编辑与相关专业专家或同行学者共同讨论稿件,有利于建立公开交流互相学习的平台、提高工作效率、提高"把关"工作透明度及培养编辑工作素养。集体选用稿终审稿件的实施办法是对终审之前环节的综合检查及交流,是对"三审制"的完善及延伸,在高校学报稿件"三审制"中起积极作用。

The＂collective-selected draft＂could shorten the time lag of reviewing manuscripts of university journals,correct the phenomenon of reviewer bias,meanwhile achieve the requirements of basic rejection rate so as to ensure the quality of the manuscript as well as the absorption of outstanding manuscripts. In the process of implementation ＂Triple-Draft System＂,the limitations of first trial and outside trial,long time reviewing lag and bias phenomenon have certain influence on the selected version. According to the collective-selected draft principles of accuracy and effectiveness,fairness,timeliness,and equality,the paper put forward the principle of evaluation criteria,which make editors and other relevant experts or scholars have chance to discuss articles,build up public communication platform to learning from each other,improve the work efficiency,prove the work of ＂check＂transparency and cultivate editorial work quality. So,collective selection draft is the comprehensive inspection and communication before the final link,is a perfection and extension of ＂ TripleDraft System ＂,and plays a positive role in the manuscript of colleges journals.