第三次浪潮的中间道路

The Failed Balance of the Third Wave

以柯林斯、埃文斯为代表的第三次浪潮宣称是在继承第二次浪潮基础上建立的,但本文认为它实际在探索一条中间道路。一条保守主义和激进主义之间的中间道路,体现为建构论和实在论的中间道路、专家权威与民主路线的中间道路、一元论和二元论的中间道路、全体具身和计算主义的中间道路、科学和非科学界限的中间道路。并且这种中间道路并不能很好地保持自己的平衡。

The Third Wave initiated and defended by Harry Collins and Robert Evans claimed itself as inheritance of the Second Wave, but this paper holds that it＇s seeking for a medium between conservatism and radicalism. It compromises on constructionism and realism, expert authority and democracy, monism and dualism, and full embodiment and algorithmism. Furthermore, this compromise cannot keep balance of itself.