开放性的《皇朝文鉴》及其背后的学术之争——兼与《古文关键》编选的比较

The Compatible Nature of The Literature Reference of the North Song Dynasty and the Academic Controversy behind It

吕祖谦所编选的《皇朝文鉴》在选文方式上是开放的,故而其选文呈现出多层次性与包容性的特点。《皇朝文鉴》的编选在同时代的理学家中产生了学术之争,反映了吕氏婺学思想的兼容性。与《古文关键》相比,《皇朝文鉴》在编选的性质、目的、宗旨上都与前者有差异性。不过,在《皇朝文鉴》编选文章的取舍方式上仍然有商榷的余地。

The Literature Reference of the North Song Dynasty compiled by Lv Zuqian（1137-1181）mani-fests compatible characteristic of Lv Zuqian’s scholastic thought. Its multifarious and open feature brings ar-dent controversy among his contemporaries,the Neo-Confucianism Philosophers. Compared with The Keys to Classical Chinese Prose,The Literature Reference of the North Song Dynasty is different concerning its charac-ter,aim and tenet. However,the way the book selects articles is open to question.