关于“编辑学者化”论争的思考

THOUGHT ON THE DISPUTE OF "SCHOLAR EDITORS

关于“编辑学者化”的论争虽然历时已久 ,但在一些基本问题上仍然众说纷坛 ,见智见仁。如“编辑学者化”中的“学者”是广义上的所有学科领域中的学者 ,还是狭义上的编辑学科领域中的学者的问题 ;编辑自身修炼中的“博”与“精”的问题 。

The dispute of 'Scholar editors'has lasted a long time,yet people still have different opinions on some aspects,For example:Does'scholar'in 'scholar editors'refer to the scholar in a broad sense or in a narrow sense?The former means the scholar in all subject fields and the latter means the scholar only in editorial subject field.Should the knowledge of editors themselves be wide or special?And etc.