台湾“戒严”时期“新文学史”著作中的“鲁郭茅巴老曹”叙述——以周锦的《中国新文学史》为中心

The relation of “Lu Guo Mao Ba Laocao”in new literary history at period of martial law in Taiwan——Focusing on Zhoujin's“Chinese new literary history”

"鲁郭茅巴老曹"在大陆"新文学史"叙述格局中处于不可动摇的核心地位,但在台湾学者周锦的《中国新文学史》中,"鲁郭茅巴老曹"却处于一种"非核心"的位置。同时,该著对于"鲁郭茅巴老曹"及其作品的评价,呈现出一种二元并立、相互缠绕的矛盾吊轨现象:一方面,对于作家作品的评判表现出某种基于意识形态的偏见;另一方面,对部分作品的评价却又呈现出客观公正而不乏学理性的特征。以上现象并非个案性的存在,而是不同程度地表现在台湾"戒严"时期产生的绝大部分"新文学史"著作中。

＂LuGuoMaoBaLaocao＂is in the heart of unshakable status in new literary history. However, in ＂Chinese modem literature history＂ of Zhoujin,＂LuGuoMaoBaLaocao＂ is in the non-core of unshakable status. At the same time, this book present two phenomena： on the one hand, there is prejudice for the Writers of judgment; on the other hand, it is objective and fair for some arts. The above phenomena perform in different degrees in new literary history books at period of martial law in Taiwan.