摘要
以哲学、宗教、法律、贸易经济、语言学和图书情报学六个学科的期刊为样本,实证分析了p指数在期刊评价中的应用效果。结果显示:p指数与总被引频次和篇均被引频次之间存在显著相关关系,能够较好地实现期刊总被引频次和篇均被引频次的平衡,是h指数的深化和升级;p指数具有较高的区分度、灵敏度和稳健性,以及良好的易获取性等优势。但是p指数也存在忽略期刊时间因素、不能呈现引文分布情况、不能反映施引文献影响力大小的缺陷。
Based on the samples of journals from six subjects, including philosophy, religion, law, trade economics, linguistics, and library and information science, this article practically analyzed the application effect of p-index in journal evaluation in order to explore its possible valuable application. The results of this study showed that p-index was significantly relevant to total citation times of a journal and average citation times of per paper, suggesting that p-index can preferably balance the journal total citation times and average citation times of per paper and it may be the upgrades of h- index. It has higher distinction degree, better sensitivity and stability, and easier acquisitiveness when compared with h- index or other journal evaluation index. However, this article also finds that p-index has some disadvantages such as ignoring of journal time factor, inability in presentation of citation distribution, and inability in reflecting the impact of literature.
出处
《情报学报》
CSSCI
北大核心
2015年第12期1246-1251,共6页
Journal of the China Society for Scientific and Technical Information
基金
河南省软科学研究计划项目(编号:142400411247)
河南省教育厅人文社会科学研究重点项目(编号:2013-ZD-081)
河南师范大学国家级项目培育基金(编号:02096400101)
关键词
p指数
H指数
期刊评价
评价指标
计量指标
p-index, h-index, journal evaluation, evaluation index, quantitative indicator