孙德谦稿本《金史艺文略》考论

Research on Sun Deqian's Manuscripts JINSHI YIWENLUE

孙德谦为民国时期目录学名家,所著《金史艺文略》稿本现藏上海图书馆(以下简称"上图稿本")。国家图书馆所藏佚名《金史艺文略》稿本(以下简称"国图稿本"),经笔者考证,亦为孙氏手稿。经反复比勘,国图稿本乃初稿本,上图稿本为后出定本。国图稿本内容完整而过于简略,上图稿本内容丰富但集部脱佚殆尽,将二本参证互补,可窥作品全貌。孙氏此作于诸家补志中最为晚出,征引详备,体例完善,考证精审,成就最大。借助此书,我们可以对金源一代著述之盛有完整而详明的了解。

Sun Deqian is a famous bibliographer during the period of Republic of China. His manuscript JINSHI YIWENLUE is hidden in the Shanghai Library. The National Library has an anonymous manuscript JINSHI YIWENLUE which it is also the Sun＇s manuscript. Through textual research, it is also the Sun＇s manuscript. After carefully comparison, we found that National Library＇s manuscript is the first draft manuscript and the Shanghai Library＇s manuscript is the final version. The content of National Library＇s manuscript is complete but too simple while Shanghai Library＇s manuscript is rich but almost lost Jibu. If put these two books together, we can know the original appearance of the book. Compared with other similar works, although it was a later one, it has detailed information, perfect system, exquisite textual research and the greatest achievement. From this book, we can have a comprehensive and vivid understanding of the writings of Jin Dynasty.