控制下交付程序性监督机制的构建与完善

The Construction and Improvement of the Procedural Supervision Mechanism of the Controlled Delivery

信任与监督是人类社会的不朽命题。高度的信任,较少的限制,便于执法人员开展工作,但是权力缺乏必要的监督,必然给社会带来巨大的风险。从刑事裁判文书来看,控制下交付与非控制下交付的界限似乎是明确的,可是对于控制下交付的具体操作而言,哪些是属于控制下交付,哪些是为了其他目的,界限并非泾渭分明。为了保障控制下交付的正确适用,应当增加适用控制下交付统计数据的透明度和准确性,保障社会公众对于刑事司法的知情权和监督权;加强学术研究,及时发现问题,提出有效对策;完善法律规范,扎紧制度的笼子,防止权力滥用。

Trust and supervision are the eternal theme of human society. Investigators are easy to carry out the work if there is no constraint. The lack of necessary supervision will inevitably bring huge risks to the society. The boundaries of controlled delivery and non controlled delivery appear to be clear from the perspective of litigation documents. For the specific operation of controlled delivery, the line is not quite distinct from each other between the reasonable and the unreasonable. How to achieve balance between trust and supervision is an important issue that can not be ignored in the process of controlled delivery. We need to strengthen the work in order to ensure the correct implementation of controlled delivery： the public need the transparency and accuracy of statistical data on controlled delivery in order to ensure the right to know and the supervision of criminal justice; Scholars can strengthen academic research, find the title in a timely manner, and put forward effective countermeasures; We should improve the legal norms and tie the cage system to prevent the abuse of power.