七部清人诗话考辨

A Study of Seven Works of Notes on Poetry Talks Written by the Authors in the Qing Dynasty

清代诗话数量庞大,内中尚有许多待发之覆。蒋寅先生《清诗话考》乃集大成之作,嘉惠学林至深。然而,上编《清诗话待访书目》中所著录的部分诗话,由于典籍亡佚,难以详加考索,以致偶有讹误,或是作者误题,或是作者佚名,或是将非诗话著作误作诗话。通过考订,可知《明诗纪事》的作者为毛晋,而非荥阳悔道人;《榕阴诗话》实乃杭世骏《榕城诗话》之误;《瓣香堂诗话》《西樵诗话》《见闻随录》《深柳堂诗话》的作者并非"佚名",均可考实,依次为林正青、顾有孝、刘文蔚、李子黼;《翠楼集诗话》乃刘云份《翠楼集》书前的小传而已,并非诗话著作。

In the Qing dynasty,there were many notes on poetry talks in which many problems were worth studying.Qinghi Huakao written by Jiang Yin contains very high academic value. However,there were errors about the authorship of some notes on poetry talks in the first part named Qing Shihua Daifang Shumu due to the lack of data,the author mistakenly naming,the author of anonymity or mistakenly taking some works as the notes on poetry talks,which makes difficult for detailed study. Through textual research,it＇s fund that the author of Mingshi Jishi was Mao Jin,not Hui Daoren from Yingyan,that the author of Rong Yin Shihua was Rongcheng Shihua written by Hang Shijun and the authors of Bian Xiang Tang Shihua,Xi Qiao Shihua,Jianwen Suilu,Shen Liu Tang Shihua were respectivel Lin Zhengqing,Gu Youxiao,Liu Wenwei and Li Zifu. In addition,Cui Lou Ji Shihua was a brief biography of Cui Lou Jiwritten by Liu Yunfen,it does not belong to notes on poetry talks.