从哥德尔的不完全定理论五行学说相生相克的不一致性

Discussion on Inconsistency of Mutual Generation and Restriction in Five-Elements Theory: Based on Godel's Incomplete Theorem

为了揭示五行相生相克学说的不一致性,探求五行相生相克学说的正确应用方法,引用哥德尔不完全定理分析五行相生相克之间深层次的关系,继而应用玻尔的互补原理寻求五行相生相克使用的正确途径。提示五行相生学说的出现,使得五行相克学说变得相对完全,而此相对的完全性导致了五行相生与相克的不一致,因而两者不能在同一条件下同时应用。尽管如此,但不可舍弃任何一方,只有两者互补应用才能构成完备的五行体系。

This paper is to reveal the inconsistency of five-phase mutual generation and restriction theory and explore the correct application method of the theory. Deep relationship among five-phase mutual generation and restriction is analyzed using Godel＇s incomplete theorem. Then Bohr complementary principle is adopted to explore the correct application method of five-phase mutual generation and restriction. This paper shows that the emergence of the mutual generation of five phases theory makes the mutual restriction of five phases become relatively complete. While this relative completeness leads to inconsistency of five-phase mutual generation and restriction. Thus the two theories cannot be applied under the same condition at the same time. Nevertheless,neither of the two theories could be given up. A complete five phases system could only be constitute if the two theories are applied complementarily.