《四库全书总目提要〈礼记正义〉》辨正

A Textual Research of the Catalogue Summary of Imperial Collection of Four “Li Ji Zheng Yi”

《四库全书总目提要〈礼记正义〉》是四库馆臣对《礼记正义》一书的整体看法,包括它的来源、版本、传播、评价等等。从整体上来说,其考证与评价是比较中肯的,但在细节方面有些错误。通过对《四库全书总目提要〈礼记正义〉》详细考证,笔者认为,四库馆臣对桥仁做大鸿胪的时间判断错误;《四库全书总目提要〈礼记正义〉》对《礼记正义》的评价比较中肯,但对卫湜《礼记集说》和陈澔《礼记集说》的评价稍有偏颇之处;《四库全书总目提要〈礼记正义〉》有避讳的字,将"玄"避讳为"元"。

The Catalogue Summary of Imperial Collection of Four ＂Li Ji Zheng Yi＂ is a general review of editors of the Imperial Collection of Four. It is a basic conception about the book of Li Ji Zheng Yi, including its origin, version, spread, evaluation and so on. As a whole, most of them are correct, but still there are some mistakes in details. Through careful textual research of this article, the paper claims that there are three places need to be noticed. First, the Catalogue Summary of Imperial Collection of Four ＂Li Ji Zheng Yi＂ is incorrect abut the time of Qiao Ren took the position of da hong lu. Second, its evaluation on Wei Shi＇s and Chen Hao＇s Li Ji Ji Shuo was a liitle biased. Third, in order to favor with the royal family, some taboos were substituted by other characters, such as yuan instead of xuan.