论《明代科举与文学编年》之失误——以其对明代核心科举文献的使用为考察中心

The Mistakes in Ming Dai Ke Ju Yu Wen Xue Bian Nian: Center on the Using of the Core Documents of Imperial Examination in the Ming Dynasty

《明代科举与文学编年》问世以来受到学界好评如潮,诚然该书在收录文集所含科举史料和首次大规模使用《天一阁明代科举录选刊》两方面均具有重要价值。然而,该书对明代核心科举文献的使用不甚充分,成为其不容忽视的失误,在一定程度上影响了其史料价值和学术价值。

Since publicized, Ming Dai Ke Ju Yu Wen Xue Bian Nian is praised highly by scholars. Indeed, the book possesses important value in absorbing the records of imperial examination from corpus and in using Tian Yi Ge Ming Dai Ke Ju Lu Xuan Kan on a large scale for the first time. However, the core documents of imperial examination in the Ming dynasty are used insufficient by the book, which become a mistake and weaken the value of the book.