P2P软件中立行为的可罚性探究——以快播案为研究视角

Brief Talking about Internet Neutrality Behavior——Analyzing the Case of Qvod Play

快播公司的P2P软件是通过网络存储空间来实现视频搜索的一种新兴模式,在给人们带来便利的同时也积聚了许多风险,成为了传播淫秽物品等犯罪行为的帮凶。基于网络发展带来的利益和刑法的谦抑性,刑法在介入P2P软件的治理时应当极为谨慎。一方面不能因为软件给我们带来了巨大的经济利益,而对其中的违法犯罪行为坐视不理。另一方面,更不应该因为P2P软件存在的弊端,而对运营市场进行过度规制,阻碍整个计算机领域的发展。治理网络视频播放平台时需要严格审查中立行为对犯罪的促进作用、中立行为的可替代性,与日常生活的紧密度以及确定中立行为的审查限度,来划分出正常的运营行为和犯罪的界限,以便达到法律效果和社会效果的统一,实现形式合理性和实质合理性的统一。

The P2P software of QvodPlay is an emerging pattern whose network storage space can achieve video searching. Not only has the technology brought us many advantages but also many risks. It has been an accomplice to diffuse obscene goods or materials. Base on the interest of the Interact and the tolerance of the criminal law, it should be cautious to govern the P2F sol= twarc. Balancing the benefits and detriments of the software; checking strictly the promoting role of the neutrality behavior to the crime and the substitutability of the neutrality behavior; confmning the close degree between the dally behavior and the neutralitybehavior; working out the rcview limit ofthe neutrality behavior. In horizon ofthis principle, we can achieve the unification of legal effect and social effect） and the unification of formal rationality and virtual rationality.