论民事鉴定决定权——从重复鉴定谈起

On the Decisive Right of Authentication in Civil Actions——Beginning with the Repeated Authentication

民事鉴定决定权之归属不明是目前我国现行民事鉴定制度诸多弊端 ,尤其是重复鉴定泛滥的重要原因之一。因而 ,明确民事鉴定决定权的归属也就是改革现行民事鉴定制度的较佳切入点。通过比较美国、日本、我国台湾的相关立法和理论 ,结合诉讼法原理论证 ,我国的民事鉴定决定权原则上应由法院享有。

The unclearness of decisive right of authentication is one of the disadvantages in current civil authentication system, especially one of main causes of abusively repeated authentication. So it is a better point in the reform of current civil authentication system to pinpoint to whom the decisive right of authentication should be attached to. With comparison to relative laws and theories in the USA, Japan and Taiwan District, this decisive right should be allocated to the People's Courts according to theories of procedural laws.