有解之秘与无解之魅——读金国政《水魅》并与韩少功、白烨、王跃文商榷

The Secret with an Answer and the Secret without an Answer:on “Shui Mei”(The Secret of Water) and the Discussion with Han Shao-gong,Bai Ye and Wang Yue-wen

对《水魅》的解读,尽管见仁见智,但唯一标准应是文本本身的价值,其他则都属于可商榷的范围。《水魅》是一部恢宏的生命交响曲,对具体的生活细部刻画精确,生活场景描述生动;《水魅》既不存在韩少功所言的"另类证词"的意义,更不存在白烨所说的什么"必然性和合理性",小说真正着力表现的是对自然、宇宙(水之魅)和生命(人之魅)密码的某种破译。

Different people has different views on ＂Shui Mei＂, but the only standard should be the text itself. ＂Shui Mei＂ is a magnificent charm symphony of life, describing the details of life and describing vividly the living sceneries. There is no abnormal testimony named by Han Shao-gong nor the ＂necessity and rationality＂ mentioned by Bai Ye. This novel tends to focus on the decode of the nature, universe and life.