顾櫰三《补五代史艺文志》小说著录失误考

Textual Research on the Errors of the Recordings of Novels of Gu Huaisan's Bu Wu Dai Shi Yi Wen Zhi

顾櫰三《补五代史艺文志》著录小说63部,其中错讹有误的33部。以按语的形式对王仁裕《金华子杂编》等33部小说依次进行考辨,再以列表的形式总结其小说著录失误情况。通过考察可知,顾氏《补五代史艺文志》小说著录的错讹,主要体现为:误收、重出、作者有误、书名有误、卷数有误、人书不符、作者不实、作者残阙、著录模糊等。此外,五代著作断代,上限以后梁建立(907)为界,下限则根据作者实际情况,以其所处割据政权归宋的时间为限。

Gu Huaisan＇ s Bu Wu Dai Shi Yi Wen Zhi（《补五代史艺文志》） is a collection of 63 novels, but 33 are wrong. First, this paper has textual research about 33 novels one by one in the form of notes. Finally, it summarizes the errors in list form. Through research we can know the book has many mistakes, such as wrong collection, duplication, errors in authors, title and number of volumes, improper author, inconsistency between the author and novel, incomplete author, confusing record. Furthermore, this paper has its own judgment on the five generation a works dating problems.