网络直播案件中录像制品的认定——兼论录像制品制度的不可替代性

The Determination of Video-recordings in the Cases of Webcasting——On the Irreplacability of Video-recording System

在网络直播案件中,电视综艺节目、体育赛事节目和电子游戏竞技赛事节目性质的认定至关重要,在一定条件下将上述三类节目认定为录像制品是合理的,也是必要的。网络直播案件中录像制品认定的关键问题包括独创性切入点的选取、录像制品独创性的有无、作品与录像制品属性的聚合、录像制品认定的论证逻辑等问题。我国《著作权法》上的"独创性"应当体现一定程度的创造性,录像制品以不具有独创性为前提。录像制品制度应当保留,不应被视听作品所吸收。

In the cases of webcasting, the nature games athletics is very important. Under certain determination of the TV variety shows, sports programs and conditions, it is reasonable and necessary to take the three programs as video-recordings. The key issues of nature determination include the selection of penetration point of originality, the originality of video-recordings, the polymerization of video-recordings, and the logical argument of video-recordings. The originality of ＂copyright law＂ in our country should reflect a certain degree of creativity. The system of video-recordings shall be kept and shall not be absorbed by audio-visual works.